Melissa Joan Hart, Caroline Rhea, Jared Logan

Actresses Melissa Joan Hart and Caroline Rhea have a mini-Sabrina the Teenage Witch reunion, and Jared Logan beats up jocks. Plus, find out who will win the title of "Best Talk Show Guest in America!"

Colin Quinn, Charles Barkley, Marissa Jaret Winokur

Colin Quinn and Charles Barkley trash-talk their way through the competition, but are they a match for Broadway diva Marissa Jaret Winokur? Plus, find out who's "Best Talk Show Guest in America!"

Fortune Feimster, Reggie Bush, Nick Thune

Actress Fortune Feimster does the ice cream dance, footballer Reggie Bush celebrates in the end zone, and comedian Nick Thune plays guitar! Find out who who'll be the "Best Talk Show Guest in America!

Cheryl Hines, Ron Funches, Michael Kosta

Actress Cheryl Hines channels Larry David while double-fisting drinks, comedian Ron Funches shows his mischievous spirit and The Daily Show's Michael Kosta brings a very special guest as his secret weapon.

Billy Eichner, David Koechner, Lauren Lapkus

All bets are off tonight, as David Koechner's disorderly style clashes with the judges. But will his disruptive play distract fellow competitors Lauren Lapkus and Billy Eichner? Watch to find out!

Tate Donovan, Kym Whitley, Cristela Alonzo

Actor/director Tate Donovan juggles his way into our hearts and actress Kym Whitley tells us about Oprah's house. But are they a match for comedian Cristela Alonzo's Golden Girls prowess?

Andy Richter, Sasheer Zamata, Nadia G

Late-night star Andy Richter spills the tea on some of Conan's biggest guests, comedian Sasheer Zamata comes dressed to impress and punk rock celebrity chef Nadia G serves up more than you'd expect!

Cynthia Bailey, Cole Escola, Andy Kindler

The shade is real when Cynthia Bailey spills the tea on her fellow housewives of Atlanta. But will it be enough to match wits with Difficult People's Cole Escola and comedian Andy Kindler? Watch to find out!

Anders Holm, Lennon Parham, Seaton Smith

Anders Holm flashes some skin, Lennon Parham shows off her dance moves, and Seaton Smith discusses geography.

Wanda Sykes, Lauren Ash, Nico Santos

Comedian Wanda Sykes is back... and she's not horsing around! Watch the reigning winner as she competes against Superstore's Lauren Ash and Nico Santos for the title of Best Talk Show Guest.

Loni Love, Andy Bell, Nicole Sullivan

The Real's Loni Love shows off her electrical engineering skills, former Jackass stuntman Andy Bell goes for a world record, and Disjointed actress Nicole Sullivan takes a gamble!

Illeana Douglas, Arturo Castro, Alex Mapa

Actress Illeana Douglas talks about her famous family and Swedish furniture; Broad City and Narcos actor Arturo Castro shows off his accent skills; and actor Alec Mapa dishes on Desperate Housewives!

Dave Holmes, Maria Thayer, Eliza Skinner

MTV vet Dave Holmes dishes the dirt on Kid Rock, Those Who Can't's Maria Thayer shows us that redheads have more fun, and comedian Eliza Skinner tries to make cat ladies cool!

Natasha Leggero, Cam'ron, Wilson Cruz

Another Period's Natasha Leggero and her dog present a united front against hip hop artist Cam'ron's confident play and the undeniable charm of Star Trek: Discovery's Wilson Cruz.

Jill Kargman, Judah Friedlander, Joel Kim Booster

Odd Mom Out's Jill Kargman throws shade on Upper East Side moms, Judah Friedlander talks about the time Dave Mathews kicked him out, and Joel Kim Booster wins the love of his life!